High Court Judge’s Orders Stayed: SC Cites ‘Mockery of Justice’
The Supreme Court on Tuesday, August 5, 2025, took the unprecedented step of restraining Allahabad High Court Justice Prashant Kumar from hearing criminal cases. The apex court’s decision follows a series of what it termed “erroneous” orders passed by Justice Kumar.
One particular order, passed in May 2025, drew sharp criticism. The SC found that Justice Kumar had wrongly upheld a criminal summons in a purely civil matter.
The Supreme Court’s judgment directly criticised the judge, stating his actions amounted to a “mockery of justice” and demonstrated a concerning lack of legal understanding. The May 2025 order has been set aside.
This landmark decision raises significant questions about judicial accountability and the maintenance of the highest standards within the judiciary. The impact on pending cases before Justice Kumar and the broader implications for judicial oversight remain to be seen. The case underscores the crucial role of the Supreme Court in maintaining the integrity of the Indian judicial system.
